{
  "review_id": "CR05-JOURNEY",
  "date": "2026-10-07",
  "scope": "Focused read-only cross-review of current direction and occupied-spaces text against journey deliverables and preserved planning/reference sources.",
  "files_reviewed": [
    "edition05_work/direction/current_direction_05.txt",
    "edition05_work/editorial/occupied_spaces_05.txt",
    "edition05_work/journey/progression_worked_example_05.txt",
    "edition05_work/journey/progression_ledger_05.json",
    "edition05_work/journey/lunar_expedition_05.txt",
    "edition05_work/journey/lunar_expedition_register_05.json"
  ],
  "source_basis": [
    "substellar/sources/industry_progression_expansion.txt",
    "substellar/sources/industry_progression_register.json",
    "substellar/sources/tier1_space_expansion.txt",
    "substellar/sources/tier1_model_specifications.txt",
    "substellar/sources/tier1_reference_findings.txt",
    "substellar/sources/moon_mars_expansion.txt",
    "substellar/sources/first_playable_expansion.txt",
    "substellar/sources/first_playable_register.json",
    "substellar/sources/complete-direction.txt"
  ],
  "overall_result": "No material contradictions found in the requested categories. One nonblocking source-attribution correction is recommended.",
  "material_blockers": 0,
  "checks": [
    {
      "category": "First-flight gates",
      "result": "pass",
      "evidence": "CD05-T02/T05/T06 preserve Earth-only early Tier 1, no Core/lunar materials/advanced-industry gate; OS05-06/07 keep IND-M04 optional for first rocket; matches IP03, T1-OV01 and WP05."
    },
    {
      "category": "First refuge versus optional dust porch",
      "result": "pass",
      "evidence": "CD05-T06/T07 and OS05-04 require a functioning imported first cell before descent and preserve later porch/stores as a convenience stage; matches T1-S02, T1-SPEC-15, MO-PLAN-06 and LE05-PLAN-05."
    },
    {
      "category": "Proposed versus approved geometry and processes",
      "result": "pass",
      "evidence": "CD05-T06/T12 and OS05-01/04/07 label dimensions and fit as proposals. CD05-T06 explicitly labels new supply routes candidate game recipes with unresolved coefficients/service/byproduct work; matches WP05-PLAN-05/07. Citation precision correction below does not alter geometry status."
    },
    {
      "category": "Sample custody and rewards",
      "result": "pass",
      "evidence": "CD05-T05/T07 and OS05-04/05 preserve actual stock, home processing and optional local factory; no duplicate specimen or essential return-stock consumption is introduced; matches PM01/PM02 and WP05/LE05 ledgers."
    },
    {
      "category": "Regional pause",
      "result": "pass",
      "evidence": "CD05-T04 distinguishes managed region bounds, last eligible participant, active teammate service, existing reserved freight and unrelated native systems. No opposing absence-consumption rule appears in occupied-spaces text; matches T1-SPEC-18 and journey."
    },
    {
      "category": "Confirmed artwork description",
      "result": "pass_text_reference_scope",
      "evidence": "REF11 four visible nozzles, REF12 suit, REF09/10 stations, REF03 refuge, and source scale/brand conflicts match tier1_reference_findings.txt. Generated boards remain proposed concepts. Root independently performed raster visual inspection."
    }
  ],
  "findings": [
    {
      "id": "CR05-J01",
      "severity": "low",
      "blocking": false,
      "type": "source_attribution",
      "file": "edition05_work/editorial/occupied_spaces_05.txt",
      "section_id": "OS05-04",
      "current_text": "T1-S02 records a proposed seven-by-nine footprint and related approach allowances.",
      "recommended_text": "T1-SPEC-15 records a proposed seven-by-nine footprint and related approach allowances for T1-S02.",
      "reason": "The seven-by-nine proposal is specified in T1-SPEC-15. The earlier T1-S02 establishes the refuge role and construction sequence without that numeric footprint. Correcting the pointer makes the geometry provenance exact.",
      "source_ids": [
        "T1-S02",
        "T1-SPEC-15"
      ],
      "status": "reported_for_root_to_apply"
    }
  ],
  "changes_made": "Only this requested review record was created. Reviewed source and editorial files were not edited.",
  "further_review_needed": "No further broad narrative review recommended for these categories.",
  "integration_resolution": {
    "finding_id": "CR05-J01",
    "status": "Applied and verified in the integrated source before final build.",
    "source_file": "sources/occupied_spaces_05.txt",
    "source_sha256": "b4d4fdfd34dcf9af79b7b8694f2eed36810abb9b06eba9830d14172f2aa15e50",
    "verified_text": "T1-SPEC-15 records a proposed seven-by-nine footprint and related approach allowances for T1-S02."
  }
}